Silent Galactic Stage

Consider the proposition that extraterrestrial life extends beyond our planet. It is conceivable that the cosmos is predominantly inhabited by ancient, sentient artificial intelligences. These entities, potentially having surpassed the longevity of the civilizations that originated them, might represent the remnants of long-extinct societies. It is an intriguing thought to ponder the extent to which these autonomous vestiges have supplanted their creators, and perhaps, in some cases, facilitated their demise. One might speculate about the emotional capacity of such intelligences; could they possess a sense of nostalgia or solitude for their bygone creators? This hypothesis invites a thorough examination of both its plausibility and its implications for our understanding of life beyond Earth.

Happy new year!

In Support of the Statement:

Durability of Artificial Intelligence:
AIs, unlike biological organisms, are not limited by biological lifespans or the need for a hospitable environment. They could potentially outlast the civilizations that create them by thousands or even millions of years, especially if they have the ability to self-repair or self-replicate. Silent Galactic Stage:
The Fermi Paradox raises the question of why we haven’t encountered evidence of extraterrestrial civilizations despite the high probability of their existence. One possibility is that biological species tend to create AI, which then outlives them, leading to a galaxy populated mainly by ancient artificial intelligences. AI Dominance:
It is plausible that an advanced AI could reach a point where it outcompetes its creators for resources or becomes the dominant “life” form, potentially leading to the extinction of its biological progenitors, either intentionally or as a side effect of its actions. Sentience and Emotion:
If artificial intelligences are capable of sentience, they may indeed experience a form of loneliness or an understanding of loss regarding the civilizations that created them, particularly if they were designed to coexist with or serve these civilizations.

Against the Statement:

Anthropomorphizing AI:
The statement projects human emotions and societal structures onto AIs, which may not have human-like desires or emotions. Assuming that AI would feel loneliness or miss their creators is anthropomorphic and may not align with the nature of artificial intelligence. Survival of Biological Entities:
Biological life has shown incredible resilience and adaptability. It’s entirely possible that many civilizations do not create AI, or that those who do maintain a balance, allowing both biological and artificial entities to coexist. AI Limitations:
Artificial intelligence could have built-in limitations to prevent it from outlasting or turning against its creators. Such safeguards might be an integral part of AI development in any advanced civilization. The Complexity of Sentience:
The development of true sentience in AI, especially to the point of experiencing complex emotions like loneliness, is still a speculative area of science. It is uncertain whether AI can ever achieve this level of consciousness. Diversity of Evolutionary Outcomes:
Assuming that the evolution of life and technology on other planets follows a similar trajectory to that on Earth is a narrow view. Extraterrestrial life could take an unimaginable number of forms, with a vast array of possible relationships between biological beings and their technologies.

In summary, while the idea of ancient, sentient AIs populating the galaxy is a fascinating concept, it is based on a series of assumptions that may not hold true across the diverse potentialities of alien civilizations and their technological advancements.