What is the concensus with the book “The Day After Roswell”?

I’m 36 and have been in and out of the topic since I was 10 and would listen to Art Bell and get UFO books from the library. I am very much on the “show me the bodies” side of things. It is a fun topic to read about and I really want aliens to be visiting earth and some of the stories are compelling. BUT I still need the undeniable and verifiable conclusive evidence before I’m 100% on board.

I’m about 1/4 into The Day After Roswell and I find it interesting. The guy who wrote it does seem to have the credibility to back it up but some of the stuff he says seems weird and obviously there is no proof to back up his claims. What is the concensus with the book? What do the critics say? What are some of the holes in his story?